Ivoo

You stated above that because it is applied to the area right ? then what about druid area Roots? it is still affected by Book and scrolls, so my suggestion is to change the mechanics of warlock area cc
there should not be any reason why warlock has the only special skill that is not affected by books and scroll that are created to lessen the duration of debuffs

Change Warlocks Dark circle and Zone of Weakness mechanics so that it would be affected by Book "Magic Resistance" and Confrontation scrolls!! make it balanced! there is no reason for warlock area cc to be special !
 
There is a saying, "when one already feel a great injustice, they would treat a lesser one as a blessings" you mean it like this? we should appreciate the things now because it could have been more broken? lols nice way of thinking

its obvious if you unity 60 people in war to 200+ people u wont last long. smh in GvG thoose 30 chiefs dont even hurt elf waves. 
 
its just you are outnumbered. Mage is class that was released together w lock, and lock skills aint stacking too like mage. 

First of all read the topic before you answer anything i wrote same on the discord, no wonder you didnt graduate your school and living on the game now, if you answer question before you read them. 
 
I was talking abt every server, didnt bring my chief to  compare, i play 4-5 different server and most of them dominated by people who using theese books arena, Raid bosses fights, gvg we aint here talking about your dirty alliance with Phalanx. and about my maces. your writing here long text and protect the unbalanced book because you own one of them. We understand you spent gold for it and afraid of not being immortal if they nerf it. 

first of all talent or expert skill combo that increases damage by 40%
 
if seeker talent makes his health 1.5k, then expert skill that works below 30% health should work at 30% health then from 450 health, because its impossible to fight them on pve damage (dps) at raid bosses, etc that talent + expert skill combo makes them broken. 
How mcs compete this? 
Hunters xbow hits 3.9 bow 3.3
seeker daggers 1.7 and their auto attacks higher with daggers than xbow hunters. 
 
2. T2 castle book.  Gives also 10% damage when your health is below 40%, and seekers talent making their hp 30% so 5 seeker party has this book permamently activated. 
 

first of all talent or expert skill combo that increases damage by 40%
 
if seeker talent makes his health 1.5k, then expert skill that works below 30% health should work at 30% health then from 450 health, because its impossible to fight them on pve damage (dps) at raid bosses, etc that talent + expert skill combo makes them broken. 
How mcs compete this? 
Hunters xbow hits 3.9 bow 3.3
seeker daggers 1.7 and their auto attacks higher with daggers than xbow hunters. 
 
2. T2 castle book.  Gives also 10% damage when your health is below 40%, and seekers talent making their hp 30% so 5 seeker party has this book permamently activated. 
 

Hi
 
What im worried about,that doesnt seem balanced is 2 Books that once got nerfed but still got very high % for being passive book. 
 
For example if you use Orcinus book on the chieftain, and unlocked all key talents and got some cooldown reduction,scroll.
1. You can have longer resistance than cooldown of the skill so basically (Permament) 
2. High duration of rugged, passive, relics. 
also you cant die when you got shaman healing on you. 
3. With perma resistance you can walk everywhere without getting stunned. (Well if 30-50+ opponents hit you with auto attacks you cant walk much but can vast rugged and other skills. 
 
For example if Healer using octopus book with lifeforce etc,castle scroll.  
 
He got insane healing from lifeforce, skills even apathy wont be able to help much, also when you cant stun him, he keeps buffing himself and stay maximum health points. Okay maybe if you go 3 vs 1 you beat him. 
 
So what u suggest. 
 
First of all we all know passive books normal %
from 3 to 10%
and its already good buffs for get from passive books, but if you watch orcinus, octopus books their % is about 50.
Just passive book with so high % and insane buff basically. 
I suggest to reduce them to 10-15% 
because 1-2 second debuff, buffs are still alot for character, because there is alot buffing skills, and debuffs. or keep it 50% and make there cooldown like for distortion of life effect. 
 
There is always on every  server one side who most of time dominate raid bosses, and how you can deal with them if they got already 5-10 of them for strong aoe classes. its very difficult for get new players arena equipment against them, win war buffs, Raid bosses, even GvG. 
 
 
Please keep passive books as some buffs for character, but not make them overpowered. 
 
 
 
 

Hi
 
What im worried about,that doesnt seem balanced is 2 Books that once got nerfed but still got very high % for being passive book. 
 
For example if you use Orcinus book on the chieftain, and unlocked all key talents and got some cooldown reduction,scroll.
1. You can have longer resistance than cooldown of the skill so basically (Permament) 
2. High duration of rugged, passive, relics. 
also you cant die when you got shaman healing on you. 
3. With perma resistance you can walk everywhere without getting stunned. (Well if 30-50+ opponents hit you with auto attacks you cant walk much but can vast rugged and other skills. 
 
For example if Healer using octopus book with lifeforce etc,castle scroll.  
 
He got insane healing from lifeforce, skills even apathy wont be able to help much, also when you cant stun him, he keeps buffing himself and stay maximum health points. Okay maybe if you go 3 vs 1 you beat him. 
 
So what u suggest. 
 
First of all we all know passive books normal %
from 3 to 10%
and its already good buffs for get from passive books, but if you watch orcinus, octopus books their % is about 50.
Just passive book with so high % and insane buff basically. 
I suggest to reduce them to 10-15% 
because 1-2 second debuff, buffs are still alot for character, because there is alot buffing skills, and debuffs. or keep it 50% and make there cooldown like for distortion of life effect. 
 
There is always on every  server one side who most of time dominate raid bosses, and how you can deal with them if they got already 5-10 of them for strong aoe classes. its very difficult for get new players arena equipment against them, win war buffs, Raid bosses, even GvG. 
 
 
Please keep passive books as some buffs for character, but not make them overpowered. 
 
 
 
 

First of all read the topic before you answer anything i wrote same on the discord, no wonder you didnt graduate your school and living on the game now, if you answer question before you read them. 
 
I was talking abt every server, didnt bring my chief to  compare, i play 4-5 different server and most of them dominated by people who using theese books arena, Raid bosses fights, gvg we aint here talking about your dirty alliance with Phalanx. and about my maces. your writing here long text and protect the unbalanced book because you own one of them. We understand you spent gold for it and afraid of not being immortal if they nerf it. 

There is more rare book which is the new rage one, but this % aint too 50%, also has cd and not overpowered so why they should be?. also each server is mostly dominated by elf side on raids, overpopulation, when elves using theese books how mc side able to get pvp sets?, only eu server is monopolized and YinYang getting theese books thanks for Elf strongest guild support, and Apparently YinYang dont use theese books vs them either so, tell me how newbies able to win stuff vs orci octopus books opponents, just pvp set aint enough even if book was nerfed to 10% people still would farm it because its still strong and removing debuff / and adding longer duration to skills. 
After all, what is your goals for this game, to get book what makes you immortal, and then you win everything 24/7? is this point of the game? if you never want to lose or get game difficult, or balanced where is the fun? 

Hi
 
What im worried about,that doesnt seem balanced is 2 Books that once got nerfed but still got very high % for being passive book. 
 
For example if you use Orcinus book on the chieftain, and unlocked all key talents and got some cooldown reduction,scroll.
1. You can have longer resistance than cooldown of the skill so basically (Permament) 
2. High duration of rugged, passive, relics. 
also you cant die when you got shaman healing on you. 
3. With perma resistance you can walk everywhere without getting stunned. (Well if 30-50+ opponents hit you with auto attacks you cant walk much but can vast rugged and other skills. 
 
For example if Healer using octopus book with lifeforce etc,castle scroll.  
 
He got insane healing from lifeforce, skills even apathy wont be able to help much, also when you cant stun him, he keeps buffing himself and stay maximum health points. Okay maybe if you go 3 vs 1 you beat him. 
 
So what u suggest. 
 
First of all we all know passive books normal %
from 3 to 10%
and its already good buffs for get from passive books, but if you watch orcinus, octopus books their % is about 50.
Just passive book with so high % and insane buff basically. 
I suggest to reduce them to 10-15% 
because 1-2 second debuff, buffs are still alot for character, because there is alot buffing skills, and debuffs. or keep it 50% and make there cooldown like for distortion of life effect. 
 
There is always on every  server one side who most of time dominate raid bosses, and how you can deal with them if they got already 5-10 of them for strong aoe classes. its very difficult for get new players arena equipment against them, win war buffs, Raid bosses, even GvG. 
 
 
Please keep passive books as some buffs for character, but not make them overpowered. 
 
 
 
 

Hi
 
What im worried about,that doesnt seem balanced is 2 Books that once got nerfed but still got very high % for being passive book. 
 
For example if you use Orcinus book on the chieftain, and unlocked all key talents and got some cooldown reduction,scroll.
1. You can have longer resistance than cooldown of the skill so basically (Permament) 
2. High duration of rugged, passive, relics. 
also you cant die when you got shaman healing on you. 
3. With perma resistance you can walk everywhere without getting stunned. (Well if 30-50+ opponents hit you with auto attacks you cant walk much but can vast rugged and other skills. 
 
For example if Healer using octopus book with lifeforce etc,castle scroll.  
 
He got insane healing from lifeforce, skills even apathy wont be able to help much, also when you cant stun him, he keeps buffing himself and stay maximum health points. Okay maybe if you go 3 vs 1 you beat him. 
 
So what u suggest. 
 
First of all we all know passive books normal %
from 3 to 10%
and its already good buffs for get from passive books, but if you watch orcinus, octopus books their % is about 50.
Just passive book with so high % and insane buff basically. 
I suggest to reduce them to 10-15% 
because 1-2 second debuff, buffs are still alot for character, because there is alot buffing skills, and debuffs. or keep it 50% and make there cooldown like for distortion of life effect. 
 
There is always on every  server one side who most of time dominate raid bosses, and how you can deal with them if they got already 5-10 of them for strong aoe classes. its very difficult for get new players arena equipment against them, win war buffs, Raid bosses, even GvG. 
 
 
Please keep passive books as some buffs for character, but not make them overpowered. 
 
 
 
 

Since last rebalance only made game worse for mc side, last rebalance alot mc classes got nerf, now globe adjusted for make elf side easier mc had no problems with this. you guys lost 2 raid boss and everyone wanted instantly nerf charmer, and you can check this by every server results, everywhere elf strongest now. 

Lets go, time to close my guild and play elf, return when game gets balanced again. 
 

Lets go, time to close my guild and play elf, return when game gets balanced again. 
 

Lets go, time to close my guild and play elf, return when game gets balanced again.